Good morning, and thanks for spending part of your day with Extra Points.

By the time you read today’s newsletter, I’ll already be on the road for Canton, Ohio. And you know why?

Tomorrow is the 2026 EXTRA POINTS BOWL.

If you’re in the NE Ohio area and want to hang out with us and watch some excellent Division III college football, you’re in luck. The Extra Points Bowl will feature John Carroll against Grove City at 6 p.m. ET at the Tom Benson Hall of Fame Stadium in Canton, right by the Pro Football Hall of Fame. If you’re not in the neighborhood, you can also watch the game on FloSports.

The Extra Points Bowl is one of my very favorite things we do with this company. We get a chance to support small college athletics in a part of the country that is very important to me. We get to watch some really good football games, connect with our readers, hopefully sell some Extra Points Classroom/Library subscriptions, and step away from the lawyers, politicians and administrative battles for a second to just watch some ball. It’ll be a great time.

But the game is tomorrow, not today. Joining us today is Molly Harry of the University of Florida, who’s share some of her thoughts on the Protect College Sports Act … a bill that still isn’t quite dead. I’ll turn the time over to her.

The Protect College Sports Act (PCSA) faces a tough path to becoming law — though maybe not quite as tough as it appeared after the midterms. And if it does end up failing, that’s not going to stop a future Congress from meddling in college sports. 

The PCSA, a bipartisan attempt to establish a federal framework for governing college athletics, passed the Senate by a margin of 77-22 in September, marking the most significant progress in Congress’s years-long effort to regulate the industry. That sent the act to the House of Representatives, but before it voted, the midterm elections sent a flood of Democrats into the House. It’s unclear how many of the Republicans voted out of office will even return to Washington between now and the end of their term, and the Democrats taking their place are generally more resistant to the PCSA — jeopardizing the bill’s future. 

Still, lawmakers could turn their gaze back to college sports at any time. And if they do, one topic deserves particular attention. It’s a question the PCSA largely ignores, despite touching nearly every major issue in college sports: Are college athletes students or employees?

Seemingly everyone has an answer to the question that has loomed for years: College athletes should be students. College athletes should be employees. College athletes should be fill-in-the-blank.

College athletes should. College athletes should. College athletes should.

From Bruno Mars to Bemidji State


From Bruno Mars and Adele to Michigan and Bemidji State, The Famous Group is helping venues create unforgettable fan experiences with interactive games, selfie cams, live polls and more.

But it's not just about entertaining fans. These activations also create new sponsorship opportunities and generate additional revenue for athletic departments, without requiring massive budgets or sophisticated equipment. Read how The Famous Group is helping schools get more out of their scoreboard here.

But has anyone bothered to ask college athletes what they think? If the PCSA winds up going nowhere, perhaps those “shoulds” provide an opportunity. Next time legislators turn their eye to college sports, they ought to try to answer the question of employment.

NCAA leaders have repeatedly argued that college athletes do not want to be employees. That might be true for some. But these athletes are not a monolith. A football player receiving substantial revenue-sharing payments may view employment very differently from a swimmer worried about whether her team will exist five years from now.

More importantly, asking athletes whether they want to become employees assumes they understand what becoming an employee might actually mean.

My research team and I recently conducted one of the first studies to examine college athletes’ knowledge of and attitudes toward potential employment. We surveyed 130 athletes across a Power 4 conference, including those from both revenue-generating and Olympic sports.

What we found complicates narratives on both sides.

More than half of the athletes (52 percent) described themselves as somewhat or very unknowledgeable about potential employee status. Some told us our survey was the first time they had encountered the idea. Nearly three-quarters said legal rights and protections, including labor law and unionization, were among the areas they understood least.

Where were athletes learning what they did know? Mostly from social media, news coverage and their teammates. Only 15 percent reported receiving information through athletic department programming or discussions with administrators.

Yet lack of knowledge did not translate into opposition to employment. Among the athletes surveyed, 46 percent viewed potential employee status positively, compared with 27 percent who viewed it negatively and 27 percent who were neutral.

Their responses also revealed why simplifying this debate to “student” or “employee” misses nuance and details on what athletes actually care about.

For instance: 68 percent of athletes were excited about the possibility of receiving employee-like compensation and benefits. Nearly half were excited about having greater input in team and athletic department decisions, and 37 percent identified legal protections as appealing.


Game-day merchandise sales are one of the most powerful ways to boost your team store’s bottom line and keep fans spending long after kickoff. Desert Cactus is the trusted partner that stocks your shelves with creative, high-quality merch without breaking your budget.

We carry easy sell-through items such as flags, sticker sheets and acrylic pieces like keychains and magnets. Plus, all of our items are designed to excite fans and drive traffic to your team store. This merch doesn't just build memories; it drives real revenue for your athletic department and creates the kind of game-day buzz that keeps fans coming back to buy more.

But athletes also saw costs; 67 percent worried about losing their scholarships. More than half worried about sports being eliminated, and nearly half feared the possibility of being fired for athletic performance concerns. When asked whether they would accept teams being eliminated in exchange for better employment benefits and compensation for themselves, 64 percent were unwilling.

And there were important broad disagreements between demographic groups. Men were more supportive of employee status than women, and athletes in higher-profile, non-Olympic sports were more supportive than those competing in Olympic sports.

Those differences should matter to lawmakers.

They also illustrate why claims that college athletes want — or do not want — employment should be treated skeptically. There is no singular college athlete position. And with this, we have remarkably little systematic evidence about what the individuals most affected by these decisions actually understand and want.

Perhaps, then, what college athletes need most is not another group deciding what is best for them. They need access to credible, independent information about their rights and the rapidly changing system around them. They need meaningful opportunities to participate in decisions that affect their education, labor and athletic careers. And they need mechanisms that allow their different interests and perspectives to be heard.